Before You Ask, Check How Long They Had to Keep It
by Chaz Stevens, CLE Faculty
Before You Ask, Check How Long They Had to Keep It
Find the records retention schedule that covers the record. Federal agencies must use NARA’s General Records Schedules unless they justify an agency-specific schedule. Florida allows destruction only under schedules the state’s records division sets, and Washington local agencies generally need local records committee approval. If the agency says the record is gone, ask which schedule item or approval authorized it.
Picture a hypothetical requester who asks a county for two-year-old inspection logs and gets a short reply: those were destroyed. The reply sounds like the end of the conversation. It is the start of a better one, because in the jurisdictions below an agency does not get to throw records away on a whim. It throws them away under a schedule or an approval, and that is the document to ask about first.
A records retention schedule is a list of record types that says how long an agency keeps each one and what happens to it when that time runs out.
Federal records leave only by the published exits
Federal law closes the side doors. Under 44 U.S.C. § 3314, “The procedures prescribed by this chapter are exclusive, and records of the United States Government may not be alienated or destroyed except under this chapter.” The chapter is chapter 33 of title 44, and the section’s own heading calls its procedures for disposal of records exclusive.
The National Archives and Records Administration says it “issues General Records Schedules (GRS) that provide disposition authority for common federal records.” On its GRS page, NARA states that the GRS cover records documenting administrative or support functions and typically do not cover records documenting an agency’s mission. NARA also states that “Use of the GRS is mandatory” and that agencies must use the GRS unless they can justify an agency-specific schedule. So for a federal record, the question to ask is which GRS item or agency schedule item covers it.
When federal records go missing the wrong way, the law requires paper. Under 44 U.S.C. § 3106(a), the head of each federal agency “shall notify the Archivist” of any actual, impending or threatened unlawful removal, defacing, alteration, corruption, deletion, erasure or other destruction of records in the agency’s custody. The regulation at 36 CFR 1230.14 says the agency “must report promptly” any unlawful or accidental destruction to NARA, and that the report must include a complete description of the records with volume and dates if known, the exact circumstances, and the safeguards set up to prevent further loss.
State and local records follow state law, and two states say it plainly
Federal records law covers federal agencies. A city, county or state agency follows its own state’s law, which is why the difference between FOIA and your state’s records law matters here too. Florida and Washington are two examples; other states write their own rules.
Florida’s rule is short. Section 257.36(6) of the Florida Statutes says “A public record may be destroyed or otherwise disposed of only in accordance with retention schedules established by the division”; the same section places Florida’s records and information management program within the Division of Library and Information Services of the Department of State. Section 257.36(5) defines agency to include any state, county, district or municipal unit of government, and lists among each agency’s duties to designate a records management liaison officer.
Washington’s rule for local governments runs through a committee. Under RCW 40.14.070(2)(a), except as otherwise provided by law and other than certain law enforcement records, “no public records shall be destroyed until approved for destruction by the local records committee.” The same paragraph adds that official public records shall not be destroyed unless they are six or more years old or one of two listed alternatives applies. A local agency can instead run on recurring schedules, and once the committee approves one, RCW 40.14.070(1)(b) makes it authority to destroy the listed records after the required retention period. Some periods sit in the statute itself: RCW 40.14.070(4) says personnel records for any peace officer or corrections officer must be kept for the officer’s employment and a minimum of 10 years after.
| Jurisdiction | Destruction rule | What a pending request does |
|---|---|---|
| Federal, 44 U.S.C. § 3314 and § 3106 | Records may be destroyed only under the federal disposal chapter; NARA’s GRS are mandatory unless an agency justifies its own schedule. Unlawful or accidental destruction is reported to NARA (36 CFR 1230.14). | Not addressed in these sources. |
| Florida, s. 257.36(6) and s. 119.07(1)(h) | Only in accordance with retention schedules established by the division. | A requested record may not be disposed of for 30 days after a written request, even if the custodian says it is not a public record; if a civil action is filed in that window, only by court order. |
| Washington, RCW 40.14.070 and RCW 42.56.100 | Local records: not until approved by the local records committee, with stated exceptions; an approved schedule authorizes recurring destruction after the retention period. | A record scheduled for destruction in the near future may not be destroyed or erased until the request is resolved. |
A written request can pause destruction, within limits
Both states limit destroying a record someone has asked for, though the limits differ. Florida’s section 119.07(1)(h), in the 2026 Florida Statutes, says a requested record “shall, nevertheless, not be disposed of for a period of 30 days” after a written request is made to the custodian, even when the custodian claims it is not a public record; if a civil action is filed within that period, the record may be disposed of only by court order. Washington’s RCW 42.56.100 says that if a request is made while a record exists but is scheduled for destruction in the near future, the agency “may not destroy or erase the record until the request is resolved.” The Florida hold is triggered by a written request, which is one more reason to put yours in writing.
Ask for the schedule item, then the authority behind the shredder
The schedule is the agency’s own rulebook for its paper, which makes it the same kind of target as naming the document you want. Here is the sequence.
- Name the record series. Describe the record as the agency would file it: inspection logs, meeting recordings, purchase orders, emails of a named office.
- Ask for the governing schedule item. Federal: the GRS item or agency-specific schedule item that covers that series. Florida: the retention schedule the agency follows under s. 257.36(6); the agency’s records management liaison officer is a sensible place to send the question. Washington local agency: the schedule approved by the local records committee under RCW 40.14.070.
- File the records request itself in writing, early. In Florida, s. 119.07(1)(h) runs from a written request. In Washington, RCW 42.56.100 holds a record scheduled for destruction while the request is pending.
- If the answer is “destroyed,” ask what authorized it. Ask which schedule item or committee approval the destruction relied on, and for any destruction list or other record of when it happened, if one exists. In Washington, local agencies seek destruction authority by submitting lists of records to the state division of archives and records management (RCW 40.14.070(1)(a)).
- For a federal record that left outside the schedule, ask for the report. Request any report the agency made to NARA under 36 CFR 1230.14 about the records you asked for.
None of this means the record still exists. A record destroyed on schedule may simply be gone, and a “no responsive records” reply can be a legitimate one. What the schedule gives you is a way to check whether the record should still be there and, if it is not, what authority the agency relied on. If the question becomes whether a destruction was unlawful in your case, that is one for an attorney licensed in your state.
The schedule says how long the agency planned to keep it. Ask to see that line.
Where REVOLT fits in
REVOLT Training works both sides of the public records table: it teaches people who file requests and runs governance diagnostics for institutions. Its Must Exist method is to find the written rule an agency adopted for itself, work out what paper it produces, and ask for that paper by name, citing the rule. The FOIA Engineering Playbook is free. The Must Exist Autopsy is a live class on public records request practice, and the Must Exist Campaign is a records engagement that applies the same method on your behalf, against an agency you name.
REVOLT does not provide legal representation or legal advice, and it does not promise that any agency will produce any particular record. Where a question turns on your own facts or your own jurisdiction, involve counsel licensed in your state. If your question turns on a specific denial, an unfamiliar exemption or another state’s statute, book a call.
FAQ
Can a government agency destroy records whenever it wants?
Not under the rules covered here. Federal records may be destroyed only under the federal disposal chapter (44 U.S.C. § 3314), Florida public records only in accordance with approved retention schedules (s. 257.36(6)), and Washington local records, with stated exceptions, only after approval by the local records committee (RCW 40.14.070(2)(a)). Other states set their own rules.
Where do I find how long a federal agency keeps a record?
Start with NARA’s General Records Schedules, which cover common administrative and support records; NARA says they typically do not cover records documenting an agency’s mission. Ask the agency which schedule item covers the record series you want.
Can an agency destroy a record after I ask for it?
In Florida, a requested record may not be disposed of for 30 days after a written request, even if the custodian claims it is not public (s. 119.07(1)(h)). In Washington, a record scheduled for destruction may not be destroyed or erased until the request is resolved (RCW 42.56.100). The federal sources cited here do not set a comparable hold, and other states write their own rules.
What happens when a federal agency loses or wrongly destroys records?
The agency must report promptly any unlawful or accidental destruction to NARA, with a description of the records and the circumstances (36 CFR 1230.14). The agency head must also notify the Archivist of unlawful destruction under 44 U.S.C. § 3106(a).
Sources
- 44 U.S.C. § 3106, Unlawful removal, destruction of records (Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School). Retrieved 2026-10-27.
- 44 U.S.C. § 3314, Procedures for disposal of records exclusive (Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School). Retrieved 2026-10-27.
- What are the General Records Schedules (GRS) (National Archives and Records Administration). Retrieved 2026-10-27.
- 36 CFR 1230.14, How do agencies report incidents? (Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School). Retrieved 2026-10-27.
- Florida Statutes s. 119.07, Inspection and copying of records (The Florida Senate). Retrieved 2026-10-27.
- Florida Statutes s. 257.36, Records and information management (The Florida Senate). Retrieved 2026-10-27.
- RCW 42.56.100, Protection of public records, public access (Washington State Legislature). Retrieved 2026-10-27.
- RCW 40.14.070, Destruction, disposition, donation of local government records (Washington State Legislature). Retrieved 2026-10-27.
About REVOLT Training
By Chaz Stevens, founder of REVOLT Training.
REVOLT Training teaches public records practice: how to anchor a request to a rule an agency wrote for itself, and how to answer the stalls that follow. It also runs governance diagnostics for public institutions. REVOLT Training is operated by The Z Production Group, Inc.
This article explains how the law and public records work. It is not legal advice, and REVOLT Training is not a law firm. For advice on your situation, talk to a licensed attorney.

Learn more about him on Wikipedia.
Sedition Isn't Free.
Go ahead, speak your mind.
Recent Musings
Exposing Hypocrisy
One Story At A Time.




